LS-Dyna runs giving...
 
Notifications
Clear all

LS-Dyna runs giving different results on new run every time with same settings

8 Posts
4 Users
3 Reactions
1,478 Views
Posts: 18
Topic starter
(@anuragdogra)
Student
Joined: 4 years ago

Hi everyone!

I have an LS-Dyna model and it was working fine but when I accessed it after 15 days it fails now (error termination). I made few changes to it and ran successfully but then again it started failing. I did not make any changes to the LS-Dyna cards or any control parameters I use to submit job on HPC clusters. How is this possible? Does my file got corrupt?

Any suggestions/comments will be appreciated!

Thanks

Anurag

Topic Tags
7 Replies




Posts: 61
(@icebreakersours)
Lab Tech
Joined: 3 years ago

@anuragdogra

Simply use diff utility in VIM or any other modern editor and ensure the job files are indeed one and the same. You can do the same thing via LS-PrePost (Model Compare).

Reply




Posts: 18
Topic starter
(@anuragdogra)
Student
Joined: 4 years ago

Thanks @icebreakersours! But my models look exactly the same between the one I submitted to the cluster and the one I have on my local machine that was working fine. Is there anything else that could lead to such behavior?

Best

Anurag

Reply




Posts: 61
(@icebreakersours)
Lab Tech
Joined: 3 years ago

All I meant to suggest you want to double-check your belief that the models are exactly the same. I know I have held that belief many times in the past only to realize that that was not the case.

That being said, while rare, it is possible that some features can give diverging results depending on the hardware. I don't remember it off the top of my head but an openly available projectile simulation has a contact card that gives dramatically different results between Windows and Linux. If you switch the card to a more hardware-agnostic card, the results look the same.

So, that said, take a step back and ensure there are no variables (like OS, CPUs, MPI, etc.) and repeat runs with the exact same keyword deck on the same hardware. Then, change one variable at a time (say, more cores). Proceed accordingly.

Reply
1 Reply
(@anuragdogra)
Joined: 4 years ago

Student
Posts: 18




Negative Volume
Posts: 647
Admin
(@negativevolume)
CEO
Joined: 6 years ago

Hi @anuragdogra

If the files are the exact same between the local and cluster/HPC simulation, then it might be something to do with the cluster and not your model. What error exactly are you getting when you try to run on your cluster?

Reply
2 Replies
(@anuragdogra)
Joined: 4 years ago

Student
Posts: 18

@negativevolume I am not getting any errors but my energy plots are different and I have seen an increase in the Total energy of the simulation once while using the same file.

Reply
(@sbrrr)
Joined: 5 years ago

Student
Posts: 15

I imagine this has been fixed by now. But for any future lost souls with a similar issue, Notepad ++ has a free 'compare' tool add on that functions pretty well even with "big" files. I put big in quotes because I'm only a student so I imagine model files can get many times larger than even my largest sims. But if they are truly exact you will know for sure.   

Reply







Share: